looks like every JP tier list has something unique from each other and have something in common. pls mind that the JP has Gate 4 and Gate 5, and mementos that we arent familiar with Fire Laharl is now a benchwarmer but i knew he went up in rank upon receiving enlightenment but didn't expect for the guy to put him as SSS. Daisy is still the same as well as Emma and Dorothea. dunno why he put Vivi and Eve in the rank. Magia Gunslinger is just a weak job even in their JE. even as Sage, Vivi is just normal and Lupinus is much better than her. im not quiet sure about Melda. all i know about her is she will get Beastmaster J+. at least Roy Mustang still clings to the list despite being outdated (only 3 gates). Water i consider Ravina as weak and the worst is that she got 2 jobs that doesnt synergize with her magic job. my Ravina is just 4/x/x. i decided to enlighten her to that point because i like her, not because she is strong or something so useful. i dunno why the guy put Ravina as S. its understandable that both Shen Mei is not in the list. its just lately that Shen Mei got his Pirate J+ (or JE+) in JP. as for EO Shen Mei, since she is a collab unit, she will get outdated/powercreeped over time wherein the other unit are getting G4/G5 and she still stuck with the starting gates. same fate for other Etrian Oddysey unit. none of them is in the list (except for Princess/Sovereign and Shaman). as an owner of EO Shen Mei (aka Dancer Shen Mei), i would say she best PVP than PVE. she doesnt have excellent damage like Zahar but her Dancer's main job kit is nice - has stun, +evasion rate, a multi-hit attack that also massively boost Agi (that guarantee u a faster next turn which is very sweet). although im displeased with her Dancer's sub job as the buff increase is too low - 20% increase in 2 turns. i hoped taga didnt give EO Shen Mei the Merchant as her 3rd job. Thunder unbelievably, Mei Fan isnt in his list. but Sophie (aka Zofia) is still there. if im right, both of them dont have yet their G4/G5. i disagree for not putting Mei Fan in the list. i hope taga gave Mei Fan a better future (G4/G5). as for Niggel (aka Corvus), he got a good G5 upgrade. Wind The most controversial for me. Why Setsuna was considered as SSS? i knew taga gave her enormous love as she has been underwhelming for ages. i looked into her info in the database but nothing seems to convince me. they gave her HB Shura but her other 2 job wont get the full benefit from it due to scaling. her J+ improves the +10 slash atk up to +30 but too far compared to Dark Masamune's +150. probably the guy just having personal bias. if the database is updated in line with jp, how the hell Tamamo get into S tier with just 3 gates and 1 JE (with 2 other job completely useless for her)? Mei Fan didnt get into the S but how come Tamamo? she is even in higher position than Dark Artemis wtf! i heard Tamamo is a popular unit in JP so lets hope this isnt just another bias. Edit: Looks like Setsuna as SSS in JP is not a joke. From what i've observed from the pvp videos, Setsuna is kicking some ass. As for Tamamo, she got J+ recently in JP. Light Neica's J+ is the cause of her spike in rank. dunno if she is an SSS indeed. Dark The list is what i expect except for Priscilla.